First of all I understand that you guys are very critique, though I want to say I do this in my free time and to be honest, I find the presentation/form of the sharp critique sometimes not that motivating. Perhaps it's just me, perhaps not, I wanted to give you guys this feedback.
Anyway, I am making the cover originally for a friend who get the Puggsy game for his birthday, so posting it to you guys is for me an extra and a tribute to the developers of Puggsy! Below a sample for the previous puggsy cover quality, the second is the new scan i found, the third is cleaned up. Is this resolution good enough for thecoverproject.net standards?

Perhaps making a page on the homepage with clear examples of quality issues you accept and what not. Makes it much more easier.
Cheers