Just got my faith restored in Craigslist. "Vintage Video Games! - $75" was the headline, and for once it wasn't the standard "N64 and 2 games" bs it always is. I ended up getting 2 4-switch 2600's with power supplies, 5 joysticks total and 1 set of paddles; a High Definition Graphics (TMSS) Genesis 1 with 1 first-party and 1 3rd party controller, as well as 2 3rd party arcade sticks (no power supply but whatever I have a pile of them) and the EA 4 player adapter; a 32x with connecting cable and power supply; and a whooooooole stack of games, the majority of which I did not have yet.
32x
Doom
Knuckles’ Chaotix
Shadow Squadron
Star Wars Arcade
Virtua Racing Deluxe
Genesis
Clue
Ecco the Tides of Time
Eternal Champions
Frogger
Genesis 6-Pak
Mortal Kombat 3
Sonic 1 NFR
Ren and Stimpy - Stimpy’s Invention
Street Fighter II Special Champion Edition
Ultimate Mortal Kombat 3
Virtua Fighter 2
Atari
Adventure
Asteroids x2
Atlantis x2
Barnstorming
Berzerk x2
Blueprint
Breakout
Centipede
Combat x2
Commando Raid
Defender x2
Demon Attack
Donkey Kong x2
ET
Freeway x2
Frogger x2
Frogs and Flies
Galaxian
Golf
Joust
Jungle Hunt
Kaboom!
Kangaroo
Laser Gates
Missile Command x2
Moonsweeper x2
Mouse Trap
Ms Pac-Man
Oscar’s Trash Race
Othello x2
Outlaw
Pac-Man x2
Phoenix x2
Pitfall
Pole Position
Q*bert
Raiders of the Lost Ark
Realsports Baseball
Realsports Football
Riddle of the Sphinx
Seaquest
Space Invaders
Star Raiders
Trick Shot
Vanguard x3
Video Olympics
Video Pinball
Warlords
Word Zapper
Yars Revenge
So yeah. $300-400ish worth of stuff for $75. I'll peel off the games I don't have and probably still make back double what I paid, even taking into account the fact that the Atari games are pretty beat up label-wise.