OK, I understand your concern.
But we do not need everyone here to agree.
Only one person here has the ultimate decicion power:
This is no democracy here!
We have an absolute ruler = snow
with his major servants = cover admins
and his minor servants = forum admins
Snowcone lets us use our judgement, so using that:
I think sharing old out of print guides, especially those that came in big boxes, can be shared.
In my opinion those equal to Manuals.
Snowcone and my fellow Cover Admins naturally have the power to over-rule this opinion if they feel I am in error.
If no opposing judgements arise feel free to share the scans of the guide.
I have Eartbound and Super Metroid big box guides and Illusion of Gaia small box (the one that is part of the manual) guides that I shall share once I manage to scan them without damaging them.