Ok you asked for it! LoL It's a long list but for me the Hall of Fame are games are ones that I grew up with and have fond memories of. Here goes (in no particular order)
NES
Legend of Zelda
Zelda 2
Metroid
Kid Icarus
Mike Tyson's Punch-Out
Super Mario 1-3
Goonies 2
Stinger
Rush N Attack
Top Gun
Gradius
Track & Field
Ghosts n Goblins
Gunsmoke
Commando
Bionic Commando
Wizards and Warriors 1-3
Final Fantasy
Faxanadu
Dragon Warrior 1-4
Castlevania 1-3
Contra
Super C
Rygar
Willow
Duck Tales
Mega Man 1-6
Strider
Legendary Wings
Wrestlemania
RBI 3
Little Samson
RC Pro-Am
Ice Hockey
Rad Racer
Star Tropics
Metal Gear 1-2
Batman
Paperboy
Othello
Kid Niki
Karnov
Ring King
Tecmo Bowl 1-2
Star Wars
Empire
all Black Label Nintendo (30)
SNES
Zelda: A Link To The Past
Super Metroid
Final Fantasy 2-3 & Mystic Quest
Blackthorne
Donkey Kong Counttry 1-3
Super Mario World 1-2
Super Mario Kart
Zombies Ate My Neighbors
Contra 3
Superman
Spider-Man: Maximum Carnage
Super Mario RPG
Hagane
Harvest Moon
Wild Guns
Lion King
Turtles 4
Killer Instinct
Chrono Trigger
Secert of Mana
Secret of Evermore
Earthbound
Castlevania Dracula X
Super Castlevania 4
Rock n Roll Racing
Ninja Gaiden Trilogy
Aladdin
Mortal Kombat 1-3
Tecmo Bowl 1-3
Super Star Wars
Super Empire
Super Jedi
Indiana Jones
Super Punch-Out
Super Mario All-Stars & Super Mario World
Super Ghouls n Ghosts
Gradius 3
Axelay
Mega Man 7, X, X2, X3
Earthworm Jim 1-2
Marvel Comic games
Breath of Fire 1-2
Lufia 1-2
Enix RPG's
I'm sure there are a few I've forgotten to list but I started to feel sorry for you if you decide to take on any of these